MONTPELIER — Fourteen-year-old Iso Bock of Glover is too young to vote in November’s elections. But the student has already lobbied Vermont legislators, brought friends to the Statehouse, and spoken publicly about who will hold political power when he is old enough to cast a ballot.
“As I look into my future, I see two Americas,” Bock told an audience at the Unitarian Church of Montpelier on Oct. 14. In one, he said, personal liberties endure. In the other, voters lose their power and politicians stop representing them.
Bock was the first featured speaker at an event put on by the Vermont Public Interest Research Group (VPIRG) and other organizations, promoting a proposal to curb corporate election spending through state law. He spoke alongside U.S. Sen. Peter Welch and Tom Moore of the Center for American Progress.
In 2010, the U.S. Supreme Court’s Citizens United decision removed key limits on political spending by corporations, labor unions, and other organizations. Bock warned that Vermont could face a flood of outside election spending. He pointed to Wisconsin’s 2025 state Supreme Court race, which cost over $100 million. About $51 million of that was spent by groups outside the candidates’ campaigns.
Citizens United allows super PACs to shout over candidates’ voices, Welch argues. He recalled a 2006 agreement with his congressional opponent, Martha Rainville, not to run negative ads. “That was the last contested congressional race in the history of this entire country where there were no negative ads,” Welch said. “And if Martha and I were running again, post-Citizens United, we couldn’t do it. We would no longer control the money that came into Vermont.”
Tom Moore has dubbed his approach a “corporate power reset.” Rather than confront Citizens United — which the Supreme Court decided on corporations’ free speech rights — Moore argues for reducing the powers a state grants corporations. States recognize corporations through state law and can change those powers in the future. States could use that authority to remove political spending from the activities those entities are permitted to undertake.
“States have had enormous powers, pretty much uniform from state to state for the last hundred years or so,” Moore acknowledges. “But every day, it is the state giving them those powers. And they have forgotten that, and we have forgotten that.”
This state power was not addressed in Citizens United, Moore said, and is anchored in centuries of corporate law. “No Supreme Court decision has ever come close to saying that a state can’t take away a corporation’s power to expend treasury funds in politics,” Moore said.
Moore pointed to S.322, introduced by Vermont State Sen. Anne Watson (D/P-Washington District) and others, as Vermont legislation taking that approach. He said its reach would extend beyond businesses to nonprofits, unions, limited liability companies, and other legally recognized entities.
Moore argues that the Republican-appointed supermajority on the Supreme Court would not rule this or similar laws unconstitutional. “It would mean blowing up foundational principles of federalism and corporate chartering powers,” he said, which to them would be like “drinking a glass of battery acid.”
The legal theorizing is already moving to the courts. A similar law passed in Hawaii this year, due to take effect in 2027, is already being challenged. Montana citizens will vote on an initiative in November that, Moore predicted, would pass. It, too, may be challenged.
The proposal would not limit spending by wealthy individuals, Moore acknowledged. But removing corporations and nonprofits as conduits would make the sources of political money more visible.
Paul Dame, the director of the Vermont Republican Party, was not at the event where Moore spoke. Reached afterwards, when the proposal was explained to him, he said, “When Vermont puts additional regulations on any kind of company that are not operable in other states, a lot of those corporations decide that Vermont’s market is so small that it’s not worth being here. We could see national employers moving out of the state.”
Paul Burns, director of VPIRG, said the proposed law would limit his own organization. “We would give up that power happily, knowing that any candidate running for office could only get their support from living, breathing human beings.”
If Vermont passes a version of S.322 next year, it could be one of the first states to do so.







