MONTPELIER — The city council has directed staff members to negotiate a compromise with East State Street property owners who are challenging a land survey that places the municipal right-of-way through portions of their homes, foundations, and yards.
At its Oct. 28 meeting, councilors considered a process that would begin with a memorandum of agreement in which property owners commit to negotiations and give up their right to formally appeal the land survey, which otherwise could further delay a road reconstruction project already years behind schedule.
Negotiations would aim to narrow the right-of-way — “to whatever that negotiated sweet spot is for everyone,” Mayor Marc Gwinn said, clarify the city’s uses of the right-of-way, and identify legal steps to address concerns about property titles.
City Manager Kelly McNicholas Kury said the city wants all affected property owners to agree to participate before negotiations begin, to avoid a situation in which an owner could challenge the survey in court after the city has already begun negotiating with others.
If property owners agree to the process, the city would begin the negotiation process in November, she said.
“Both sides are going to have to come to the middle,” Councilor Sal Alfano said about property owners and the city.
Councilor Paul Costello said the hope is to find a right-of-way boundary that preserves room for potential future improvements, such as a bike lane or tree planting.
Public Works Director Kurt Motyka said the goal is to resolve the right-of-way dispute in order to avoid further delaying the East State Street reconstruction project, which includes replacing water and sewer lines, sidewalks, and pavement. Voters approved the project in 2022, and the city secured a $5 million U.S. Department of Agriculture grant, which required the road be surveyed. Motyka said the project can go out to bid, but the USDA won’t release funding if the right-of-way is under dispute through a formal appeal.
Property owners have challenged the survey’s accuracy several times, saying they had no records showing the city considered parts of their properties to be within its right-of-way. The city reviewed their concerns but ultimately filed the survey in the land records on Oct. 6.
Several property owners expressed reservations about the proposed negotiation process at the Oct. 28 meeting.
Josh Mulholland, of 110 East State Street, said the surveyed right-of-way extends about a foot into his house; he understood it to end at the foundation when he bought the property, he said. He questioned whether enough property owners would agree to the proposed process.
“You probably don’t have sufficient agreement among property owners to advance the memorandum of understanding as you may wish,” he told councilors.
Montpelier resident Chris Owen read a letter on behalf of East State Street property owner John Anderson, who wants an agreement resolving the right-of-way dispute rather than a memorandum of agreement that would limit his right to appeal. Anderson wrote in the letter that he would appeal if the city does not reach an agreement on those terms by late January.
Other property owners raised concerns about the current survey’s potential consequences for their homes and property values.
Maria Arsenlis, who owns 74 East State Street, said three attorneys had told her the home would be unsellable with the surveyed right-of-way running through its living room.
“You can imagine how it would feel to have your home declared unsellable by an action of your own city,” she told the council.
Damien Leonard, a First Avenue resident, spoke as a concerned neighbor and an attorney with experience navigating boundary disputes. “With clouded title[s], houses lose value,” he said.
Patrick Coyle said he bought his home at 89 East State Street four years ago after a title search found no conflicts with the deed and showed clear property boundaries. But the city’s survey now shows the right-of-way running through half of his mudroom.
“This can cause financial ruin for your constituents,” he said. Coyle also criticized the city for its lack of communication with property owners, saying he learned about the survey from neighbors.
Some residents also faulted city staff members for long delays in responding to their questions and concerns about the survey.
“This is a group that’s lost trust in this city,” Councilor Jim Sheridan said.
Gwinn also addressed the breakdown in trust, telling property owners that it “takes a lifetime to build and can be broken very easily. One of the things that’s going to be critical to this process is that we find a way to establish and regain and re-earn each other’s trust, particularly from us to you,” he said.







