MONTPELIER — East State Street property owners are still disputing a land survey conducted as part of the city’s planned reconstruction of the road, saying it misinterprets historical records and places the boundary of a municipal right-of-way through their properties, including several homes.
In a Sept. 15 letter to Montpelier Mayor Marc Gwinn and city councilors, residents representing eight affected East State Street properties proposed the city survey and document only the land needed to rebuild the road. If the project requires land outside the existing road footprint, they proposed negotiating with the property owners whose land is needed.
They say the approach could avoid legal costs if property owners challenge the broader survey in court.
The land survey, completed last April, is required for the city to secure a U.S. Department of Agriculture grant that would fund much of the roughly $8 million reconstruction. The project includes replacing water and sewer lines, repaving the road, and rebuilding sidewalks, and the survey must be finalized before the project can go out to bid. The road project itself, however, does not require all of the land encompassed by the right-of-way shown on the survey, Montpelier City Manager Kelly McNicholas Kury told The Bridge. The city wants the broader right-of-way documented anyway, McNicholas Kury said, because it represents a property interest the city believes it has and wants to preserve for potential future municipal needs.
“The city has to really consider its property rights with all taxpayers in mind,” she said.
The dispute over the survey has already delayed the project — originally approved by voters in 2022 — by about a year. In an Aug. 29 email to residents, McNicholas Kury said the city had spent that time working with the surveyor and additional attorneys, who reviewed the survey and upheld its findings in a closed session with the city council. She acknowledged “substantive differences of conclusion” between the city’s surveyor and technical team and some property owners.
She stressed that retaining the right-of-way does not mean the city owns the land or plans to interfere with how property owners use it, but the city can use that land for municipal purposes without the owners’ permission.
Montpelier Planning and Zoning Administrator Meredith Strobridge Crandall said it’s a common enough occurrence for property owners not to know where the line falls between a public right-of-way and privately owned land. “It’s not unusual for someone to come to us, want to build something and think they own the land up to the sidewalk, and they often don’t. Usually that doesn’t go through someone’s structure, but it can. It’s an old city with a lot of very old structures,” she said.
Several property owners who spoke with The Bridge said they still have questions about what rights the city would have to use land within the right-of-way and how that could affect their homes’ value. They want the city to meet with them as a group to address their concerns.
For Miah and Vanessa Sargent, the dispute is not abstract: The right-of-way boundary in the survey cuts through the kitchen, living room, and foyer of their home at 54 East State Street.
Miah Sargent grew up in the house and returned in 2018 with his family. His father, who lived in the lower level, began researching the disputed right-of-way when the city first surveyed the property in 2025 and died about two months ago, leaving Miah and his brother to inherit the house. They now have questions about how the right-of-way could affect the home’s value and whether they should be paying property taxes on land the city says has long been within its right-of-way.
“No one wants to inherit that messiness,” Vanessa Sargent said.

Other property owners share the same concerns.
“I do have questions about the marketability,” Samuel Buckley said of his home at 48 East State Street, which he bought five years ago after previously living there as a tenant.
“I wouldn’t have bought the house if I knew I’d be dealing with a potential headache like this,” he said.
Buckley, the Sargents, and other property owners on the north side of East State Street have placed bright pink and orange surveying flags along the boundary shown in the current survey, tracing lines that cut through lawns, driveways, porches, and homes.
Maria Arsenlis, whose own disputed right-of-way runs through her living room at 78 East State Street, came up with the idea of placing the flags in late September so neighbors could better visualize how the boundary cuts across their properties.
Arsenlis, who has a background in law and engineering, said she spent several months researching land records and past surveys of East State Street. She argued the current survey incorrectly plots the right-of-way boundary in places, including near Cedar Street and West Street, where it jogs out into several properties. She said she found no records showing that some of the properties now crossed by the right-of-way boundary were ever subject to an easement, purchase, or other agreement with the city to establish the right-of-way on their land. She sent her research to the city last May in a 38-page packet.
Arsenlis joins other property owners in calling for an in-person meeting with city officials to pose questions about the survey and its impact on their properties.
Going forward, McNicholas Kury said property owners can formally appeal the survey or seek an injunction that could halt the project while a court considers the dispute. The city anticipates beginning work on East State Street next year, she said, and is “very sensitive” to further delaying a project that has already been in the works for about four years. Voters approved $7.2 million for the project in 2022, but the estimated cost has risen to about $8 million.
Correction: A previous version of this story misstated the city’s rights regarding the East State Street right-of-way. The city can use land within its established right-of-way for municipal purposes without the property owners’ permission.







