Montpelier Council to Offer 20 City-Owned Acres for $1 to a Developer for Housing

October 27, 2025
Montpelier City Councilor Cary Brown addresses the Council during its Oct. 22, 2025 meeting. ORCA screenshot.

The wheels have been set in motion to find a developer to create housing on a 20-acre buildable parcel at the Country Club Road property in Montpelier for the land price of $1. The Montpelier City Council met on Oct. 22 and voted to authorize Acting City Manager Kelly Murphy to issue the request for qualifications (RFQ) on Monday, Oct. 27, instead of immediately, after lengthy discussion. 

The choice to delay the issuance by a few days came from Councilor Adrienne Gil, in order to allow a few days for city staff members to communicate the proposal to the public.

Discussion on the proposal, led by Stephanie Clarke, vice president of White + Burke Real Estate Advisors, centered on process and purchase price. The recommendation was to start with an RFQ before issuing an RFP (request for proposals) in order to capture interest and vet qualifications before moving to detailed proposals. This would move the process along, and opens the door for more partners, according to Clarke.

The Country Club Road subcommittee would then vet the group, discuss how to clearly communicate details within the RFQ to residents, and create a short list of developers to be invited to submit detailed proposals, which would then come back to the full city council. The primary goal is to make housing doable in Montpelier, recognizing that statewide it’s nearly impossible to build without subsidies, Clarke said.

$1 Land Price Controversy

A significant part of the discussion revolved around the proposal to sell the approximately 20 buildable acres for $1 to a potential development partner. The arguments in favor of the plan came from Clarke and councilors Cary Brown, Ben Doyle, and Sal Alfano. Selling land for $1 acts as an investment or subsidy to the housing project, making it financially viable for developers. If they can’t get this incentive, they’ll build where rents are higher, such as in Chittenden County, Clarke said. Montpelier residents voted to purchase the land for $3 million with the main purpose to improve and expand housing and recreation, not to recoup the money directly from the sale, Councilor Cary Brown said.

“We didn’t spend that money thinking we would get that money back. We spent that money thinking we would get housing and recreation,” Brown said, adding that the “incredible cost” of construction now makes it almost impossible to build something that could have been built 30 years ago. 

Councilor Ben Doyle said charging $1 for the land sends a signal that the city is “going to partner with you,” versus “we are going to recoup the cost.” Doyle reminded those present of the former M&M Beverage property between Shaw’s supermarket and The Drawing Board that has had two RFPs issued with no takers. Doyle said the $1 land offer would create a catalyst to create other development. Councilor Sal Alfano said “it is a shock to see we are selling 20 acres for $1,” but by doing so, it would allow the city to pay for infrastructure through the tax base and create new tax revenue going into the future. 

“And we also would have housing that we desperately need and will nourish economic development,” Alfano said. “We are trying to attract as many developers as we possibly can.”

Those against the $1 land price included Councilor Jim Sheridan, who said he was “bothered” by the $1 price, noting the city paid about $20,000 per acre. He worried about giving away 20 acres with “no clue how much this is going to bring in for our tax base.” Councilor Gil expressed caution and emphasized the need to project scenarios and obtain a cost-benefit analysis, for example, “if we build X houses, it results in XYZ tax revenue” to justify the subsidy to the public.

The RFQ document specifies the city will partner to develop a subdivision plan, build infrastructure, and transfer ownership for $1. Water and wastewater allocation fees will be waived. The objective is to increase market rate housing, workforce housing, or both outside the floodplain, the document states.

Water and Sewer Finances Presented

Finance Director Sarah LaCroix and Department of Public Works Director Kurt Motyka made presentations about the city’s water and sewer financial situation. Unlike other city departments, Water and Sewer operates on self-contained funds and is run like a business funded by usage fees. It also charges for services such as leachate processing and is not funded by taxes.

The largest expenses are filtration, administration, and debt service. LaCroix said the water treatment plant debt will be off the books in 2025. The focus for the water department is on replacing pipes in areas with the most breaks. Those areas are Bingham Street from Liberty to East State, East State Street, Walker Terrace Street, and Nelson Street from Barre Street to Ridge Street. Focusing where the largest number of line breaks occur complies with a new city requirement to reduce areas with the most water released to address health implications from boil water notices.

The sewer department will focus on combined sewer overflows. The Water and Sewer department recently hired a company that removed 20 tons of debris from the collection line along the bike path in a FEMA-funded project that helped drop the number of sewer overflows. The accumulation came after the flood of 2023. Also, the wastewater plant generates revenue from hauled waste (sludge and food waste) from other municipalities, with a record revenue of $1.4 million in the prior year.

Staffing Levels Discussed

The city council also heard from representatives with Acrisure, a national business and insurance consulting company that conducted a Montpelier municipal staffing assessment to understand the impact of recent and proposed position eliminations, according to their report. 

Those job cuts that were not restored from 2024 include one Department of Public Works position, one recreation position, one police patrol officer, and the AmeriCorps/Youth Conservation Corps program. New cuts in 2025 were one Parks and Recreation Maintenance position, one Montpelier Senior Activity Center communications/development coordinator, two part-time finance positions, one part-time assessor assistant, and the executive assistant to the city manager, documents state.

The Acrisure study focused on workloads and service level effectiveness with an eye toward eliminating overtime expenses and staff burnout. The Acrisure representatives gathered information by interviewing the city’s human resources director, acting city manager, and department heads. 

Councilor Gil stressed the need for outside-the-box thinking and creative staffing strategies to deal with an uncertain financial future, because the community hasn’t grown in 20 years. Resident Dave Bellini criticized the report, calling its findings — such as the need for more employees to reduce overtime — as “basic management 101.” He also questioned the cost of hiring a consultant to conduct such a study. Resident Peter Kelman questioned the study’s timing, saying it is inappropriate to make staffing decisions before a new city manager is hired. He also asked why interviews were limited to department heads and managers instead of including other staff members and residents.

No action was taken.

Central Vermont Events Calendar

View full calendar

Letters to the Editor

Have something to say about this? Submit a letter to the editor!

Send a news tip

Do you know of something going on we should cover? Let us know about it.

Submit an event

Organizing an event? Submit it to our ever-growing calendar.

Latest from City News

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.

Go toTop

Don't Miss